Court Reporter

A Beitbridge magistrate has dismissed a US$10 000 defamation lawsuit filed by the Municipality of Beitbridge’s Director of Engineering Services, Douglas Martin Siphuma, against his subordinate, engineer Timothy Kadyamusuma.

Provincial magistrate Ferenando ruled Siphuma failed to prove the authenticity of a contested WhatsApp message.

In the judgment delivered on October 27, Ferenando ordered Siphuma to pay legal costs on the ordinary scale after finding critical evidentiary flaws in his case.

Siphuma had sued Kadyamusuma for injuria, alleging that on April 23, 2026, his junior at work sent him a WhatsApp message calling him corrupt and a fraudster.

The plaintiff claimed the message accused him of soliciting a US$10 000 bribe from a contractor, committing fraud regarding the Wamulala Road.

It also spoke of some plotting to force Kadyamusuma out of his job.

Kadyamusuma trough his lawyer Maphosa of Musina Law Attorneys denied sending the specific words alleged, arguing that while he had retracted and apologised for a prior communication on April 24, the plaintiff suffered no proven loss.

Ferenando said Siphuma bore the legal burden to prove on a balance of probabilities that Kadyamusuma authored the offensive text.

“However, the plaintiff’s sole piece of evidence was a printed screenshot of a message he had forwarded to his lawyer’s phone,” said Ferenando in his ruling.

During trial, Siphuma conceded that the screenshot lacked Kadyamusuma’s name and phone number, instead displaying another person’s name in the header.

Further, Siphuma failed to produce his own mobile phone containing the original message or satisfy admissibility rules for computer-generated evidence under the Civil Evidence Act.

The court also highlighted inconsistencies between Siphuma’s court summons, which cited a contractor bribe, and his oral testimony, which referenced school fees and a dossier.

Ferenando concluded that no nexus was established linking Kadyamusuma to the alleged defamatory words and dismissed the claim in its entirety.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *