By Panashe Karidzagundi
A Beitbridge prosecutor, Reason Mutimba has said lack of sufficient evidence continues to weaken some criminal cases, making it difficult for courts to secure convictions.
The remarks were made during a Crime Liaison Committee meeting held in Beitbridge on Tuesday, this week.
Mutimba was responding to concerns raised by residents and business leaders, who expressed frustration over what they described as weak prosecution of robbery suspects.
Community member Mr Ngwenya said the public was losing confidence in the justice delivery system, alleging that dangerous criminals were being released shortly after arrest.
“There is a perception in the community that robbery cases are not being taken seriously. Dangerous criminals seem to be getting away with these crimes even after the business community contributes resources to assist police in arresting them,” he said.
Pastor Mabhena also raised concern after recounting a murder case involving one of his church members.
“One of our church members was murdered and when we attended court, one of the accomplices was released. This is causing serious concern in the community,” he said.
Speaking during the meeting, Mutimba explained that courts rely heavily on evidence before making rulings.
Mutimba said many suspects are acquitted or granted bail because of insufficient evidence directly linking them to crimes.
“Every aspect we deal with in courts is based on evidence. If there is little evidence, it becomes difficult to secure a conviction,” he said.
He gave an example of a robbery case involving three suspects where only footprints were discovered at the crime scene.
“Without tangible evidence, that alone may not be enough. That is why sometimes some people are set free after court proceedings,” said Mutimba.
On drug-related offences, Mutimba said investigations require strong physical and linking evidence to prove the involvement of accused persons.
He also clarified that bail is a constitutional right and courts only grant it after considering specific legal conditions.
“People should understand that bail is a constitutional right. There are conditions that a person must meet before being granted bail, which is why some accused persons are seen back in the streets,” he said.
Mutimba urged members of the public not to fear suspects released on bail.
“To members of the public, do not fear these people because they are bound by bail conditions that legally restrict some of their freedoms,” he said.
He added that serious robbery-related bail applications are handled at the High Court.
Mutimba acknowledged that delays in court processes sometimes contribute to accused persons being released, but said Beitbridge magistrates and court officials were now working tirelessly to speed up cases.
“Lack of progress in some matters can result in people being released, but these days we are no longer delaying cases. We are working on fast-track systems because delays can cause witnesses to lose interest in cases,” he said.
Mutimba said there is no fixed timeframe for the completion of trials, as each case differs depending on the evidence and legal processes involved.
“We do not have a prescribed period because we do not know how long a trial will take. Justice must be given freely and people must be allowed to express themselves in court,” he said.
Among the issues discussed during the meeting were robbery cases, drug abuse, smuggling activities, unlicensed drivers, vehicle roadworthiness compliance, deportees, court cases, house numbering in Beitbridge, crime trends, and achievements recorded in previous months.
Stakeholders at the meeting reportedly agreed on the need for stronger cooperation between law enforcement agencies, businesses, and the community in fighting crime in Beitbridge.